Drum Kit and Gear

Acoustic Drum Set vs Electronic Drums: Which to Buy

Acoustic or electronic drums? Compare noise, space, cost, feel and learning features to decide which kit fits your home, budget and goals.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. How they differ
  3. Noise
  4. Space
  5. Cost
  6. Feel and learning
  7. Maintenance
  8. A hybrid approach
  9. Which should you buy?

Short answer

Neither type is better in every situation. In general, an electronic kit suits you if you need to practice quietly or have little space. An acoustic kit suits you if you have a place where loud playing is acceptable and you want the feel and sound of real drums. The rest of this page explains how to weigh that up.

How they differ

An acoustic drum set produces sound from vibrating drumheads, wooden or metal shells and metal cymbals. Nothing needs to be plugged in. An electronic drum set uses pads (usually rubber or mesh) fitted with sensors, plus a sound module that turns your hits into sounds. You listen through headphones or speakers.

People sometimes call the second type an “electric” kit, and the first a “regular” or “traditional” kit. In both cases it’s still a drum set, or drum kit. For the basic parts that both types share, see our drum set guide.

Noise

This is the factor that decides most purchases. Acoustic drums and cymbals are loud, and the sound carries through walls and floors. Estimates of playing volume are often given at 100 decibels or more at the player’s position, and even gentle playing is noticeable to neighbors in a shared building.

Electronic kits are much quieter in the room. The sticks on mesh heads still make a tapping sound, and the kick pedal can transmit thumping through the floor, but through headphones the drummer hears the full sound while everyone else hears far less. If you can only practice early, late, or beside people who are sleeping, an electronic kit may be the only workable option. If you already own an acoustic kit, see how to soundproof a drum room on a budget.

Space

A full acoustic kit takes up a fixed footprint, often cited as something like 5 by 6 feet, plus room for you to sit and move. Electronic kits are usually more compact, and some fold or collapse for storage. If the kit has to share a bedroom or living space, that difference can matter. Measure your space before you buy either type.

Cost

Prices vary by brand and model, so treat these as rough ideas only. Entry-level packages exist for both types, often in the range of a few hundred dollars, with a mesh-head electronic kit commonly costing somewhat more than a basic acoustic package. Both can climb into the thousands at the professional end.

Watch for the extras:

  • Acoustic: cymbals are sometimes sold separately, and you’ll also need a throne, sticks, and eventually new heads. See how much drums cost for a fuller breakdown.
  • Electronic: you’ll likely want good headphones, a throne, and possibly an amplifier or monitor speakers if you don’t want to rely on headphones alone.

Feel and learning

Acoustic drums give the most direct feedback. Stick rebound, dynamics and cymbal response are all real, and many teachers like students to learn on them. Mesh pads on good electronic kits can be close on the drums themselves, and cymbal pads tend to feel less like the real thing.

Electronic kits offer other learning advantages: built-in metronomes, play-along songs, and the ability to record. Many connect to a computer or phone over USB or MIDI, which can help with lessons and recording. The same hands-on skills transfer between the two, though switching takes some adjustment, particularly for cymbals and hi-hat.

Maintenance

Electronic kits need little upkeep beyond cleaning and checking cables, although you may eventually replace worn mesh heads. Acoustic kits require tuning and periodic head replacement; see how often to change drum heads. Cymbals on acoustic kits can also crack with heavy use.

A hybrid approach

Some players mix the two, for example adding electronic triggers or a quiet practice setup to an acoustic kit. Mesh heads and cymbal mutes can also reduce an acoustic kit’s volume, though they won’t make it silent. Another common path is to start with an electronic kit to learn at home, then add or move to an acoustic kit later if circumstances change.

Which should you buy?

  • Choose electronic if you live in a shared building, practice at odd hours, or have limited space.
  • Choose acoustic if you have a garage, basement or understanding neighbors, and the feel and sound of real drums matter most.
  • If you’re buying for a child, see junior drum set assembly and setup; the same noise and space trade-offs apply, and a quieter option is often easier to live with at home.

Whichever you pick, the best kit is the one you’ll actually play regularly.

The complete guide to drum kit and gear

The Drum Set: Parts Information and Facts
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →